A Book of a Different Structure

Our most recent reads, Monster and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, have a somewhat nontraditional structure: the film script and illustrations, respectively, depart from the chapter-based text form that YA novels usually take. I’ve noticed this as a trend in a whole bunch of other YA books as well, actually, including ones that I loved when I was younger. Here are some examples:

  • The Invention of Hugo Cabret by Brian Selznick is told half in drawings (not quite like a graphic novel, since there is no accompanying dialogue) and half in text. I really loved this one because the art and prose are harmonious but also tell you a lot of different things about the characters depending on the style.
  • Scattered throughout the text of Sleeping Freshmen Never Lie by David Lubar are a variety of different lists that the protagonist “writes” to understand high school and his life.
  • Ransom Riggs inserted vintage photographs throughout Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children to help set the mood and supplement the characterization.
  • TTYL by Lauren Myers was pretty popular when I was in middle school, and the structure was very different from all of the other books I read: it was written entirely in instant messages.

I found a compiled list of other books that fit this particular category of nontraditional formats.

Do nontraditional structures make these books more interesting for young readers? For me, it definitely made a difference – although I read virtually every book I could get my hands on, the ones I often lingered over were unusual either in story or structure.  Sleeping Freshmen Never Lie was one of my favorite books in middle school and I reread it probably half a dozen times. I also read The Absolutely True Diary several times in that same period. I can’t speak for other readers, obviously, but for me the different formats stood out from the traditional novel structure; a lot of my favorite books from my adolescence would fit in this category.

One response to “A Book of a Different Structure”

  1. First off, thanks for providing this list! I will definitely be checking it out. I agree that books that take on a different structure like the one you mentioned are very important because they open up reading to new audiences who may not have found YA lit enjoyable in the past. Personally, I think learning through images is very helpful, so the Alexie book in particular was really cool in my opinion. Overall, I believe that by authors creating YA novels in structures that depart from the norm, whatever the norm may be, the amount of people who can participate in and engage with these kinds of texts will increase exponentially.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment